In my opinion, the judging is unfair. There should be a competent jury, which knows music, and it should give at least 70% of results. Firstly, everyone can change an IP illegally and vote for himself. Secondly, the contestants can just ask their friend from other schools to vote for them. Thirdly, those who vote will mostly vote because "the singers" are their friends, not because they sing well. And I can tell you for sure that, for example, #1 sang completely out of tune. At the other side, sound technicians were really awful: there were troubles both with the microphone and the music, and it sounded absolutely unprofessionally and very unpleasantly.
To sum up, the contest was unjust, unprofessional and looked like karaoke in village club. Wait for link to some episodes from this contest.
...everyone can change an IP illegally and vote for himself. Secondly, the contestants can just ask their friend from other schools to vote for them. Thirdly, those who vote will mostly vote because "the singers" are their friends, not because they sing well.
I agree with you that contestants can do that. It happens in all the Internet polls.
Quote (Dr. Gebbels)
In my opinion, the judging is unfair.
Do you think that judging at real Eurovision contests is fair?
Quote (Dr. Gebbels)
To sum up, the contest was unjust, unprofessional and looked like karaoke in village club.
It takes time to prepare a good contest in a professional way. Why not have some fun in an easy way and relax sometimes?
I liked the performance of some contestants a lot. So, I think it's worth having such a contest. And to my mind it really does not matter who wins in fact.
P.S. As for the links, you can make a video public only with the permission of those who are taken on the video.
[quote=MsByzova]I agree with you that contestants can do that. It happens in all the Internet polls.[/quote]
That is why there should be a jury.
[quote=MsByzova]Do you think that judging at real Eurovision contests is fair?[/quote]
But should you act absolutely like at real Eurovision? It's clear that Eurovision is now more political contest, then musical. For example, Germany won only because of its great sums invested in the Eurovision contest.
[quote=MsByzova]It takes time to prepare a good contest in a professional way. Why not have some fun in an easy way and relax sometimes? I liked the performance of some contestants a lot. So, I think it's worth having such a contest. And to my mind it really does not matter who wins in fact.[/quote]
But there should be at least normal sound! Even without talking about lighting, decorations or singers, there should be better sound.
[quote=MsByzova]P.S. As for the links, you can make a video public only with the permission of those who are taken on the video.[/quote]
If they agreed to perform, they aren't ashamed about themselves. And if they aren't, they won't mind.
That's a good idea. But I don't mind Internet polls.
Quote (Dr. Gebbels)
But should you act absolutely like at real Eurovision?
Just for fun! Don't you think that it's just entertainment.
Quote (Dr. Gebbels)
If they agreed to perform ...... they won't mind.
It does not matter whether the contestant was good or bad. According to the law of media personal protection you can make any personal information public only with the permission of those who are involved.
i agree with Dr. Gebbels/ the judging is unfair( я согласна с Dr. Gebbels голосование не совсем четное) победит тот у кого больше всего знакомых в школе и друзей В КОНТАКТЕ) должно было быть хоть какое то жури, кто бы разбирался в музыке и в вокальном исполнении, что бы хотя бы 60% зависило от их выбора..
Your post has been deleted.
Please use English for communication on the site. If you have problems with your English spelling, use a TRANSLATOR or MULTITRAN.
i think it's very creative and interesting idea to hold this contest, because every child can show what he can and who he is, but i agree that judging is unfair i filmed it too i can either post it here, or just bring it to gymnasium, or post it in youtube. then we will see, what is fair and what is not as musician, i can tell you that i would give the first place to Roma for his artistic talent, second one to Ella for professionalism and the third to №10 and №6 this would be fair i think there should not be such unfair contests, it is better to make just a concert
Click on the link and read what Tetyana Mykolayivna Kondratenko ( the head of the "Troyeshchyna" gymnasium Eurovision Organizing committee) said in her interview about the jury of the contest.
[quote=MsByzova] Click on the link and read what Tetyana Mykolayivna Kondratenko ( the head of the "Troyeshchyna" gymnasium Eurovision Organizing committee) said in her interview about the jury of the contest. [/quote]
" [no name]: Who will be in jury? Tetiana Mykolayivna: English teachers and some pupils. "
A poll is a way to demonstrate publicly your poit of view. It's a pity some people use it the wrong way.
Quote (Guest)
as musician, i can tell you that i would give the first place to Roma for his artistic talent, second one to Ella for professionalism and the third to №10 and №6
The poll is very close to your choice. At least 3 contestants, mentioned by you, are among the best.
Quote (Matilda)
i think there should not be such unfair contests
The poll has no right to make the final decision. The jury will do that. You can read about it in the interview, which Tetiana Mykolayivna Kondratenko gave in December when preparations for the contest began.
"Troyeshchyna" Gymnasium Land
